Thursday, 16/08/2018
13:30 - 15:00

1. Four meanings of the word "BEING":

- Primary meaning: existence

- Three secondary copulative meanings: "to be" something; a member of a "class" which exists within and depends on the "class".

- What is the difference between Ontology (Metaphysics/Aristotle) which studies of being (or of things) in so far as they are beings ("being qua being") and all others sciences that study a certain domain of being under different aspects?

2. Existence and facts:

- Real existence: perceived or can be perceived by senses;

- Real existence exists in relationships with other real existence through categories;

- Such relationship is known as fact; thus, we don't say the event "is", but "is the case" ® Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889-1951): "The world is all that is the case. The world is the totality of facts, not of things."

The question: "what exists" can be more precisely rephrased into "what facts?"

3. Physical and psychological events:

- External and internal senses of perception;

- Broadly speaking, psychological or cognitive events are perceived by internal senses;

- Mental activity processes and eye movements during dreams can be precisely tracked but why other people can't dream my dreams?

4. Semantic existence and Semantic fact:

- Semantic existence (vs. real existence) and Semantic fact (vs. real fact) are randomly created by humans without limits;

5. Existence of universals, fictitious objects and nihility?

6. Relationship between real existence and semantic existence?

7. Readings and other referential materials:

* Bùi Văn Nam Sơn: "Tồn tại và Dấn thân: hai nẻo đường của thuyết nhân bản", in Trò chuyện triết học, tập 3, NXB Tri thức, 2017.

- Jean-Paul Sartre, "Về sự hiện hữu" in Buồn nôn. Phùng Thăng dịch. Phiên bản điện tử:

- "A History of the Notion of Being in the West":

- John Wild. "The Concept of Existence", in The Monist, Volume 50, Issue 1, 1 January 1966, pp. 1–16.

This site uses cookies to provide a better user experience.

Essential cookies are active by default and are necessary for the proper functioning of the website. Analytics cookies gather anonymous information for us to enhance and monitor the site. Performance cookies are employed by third parties to optimize their applications (such as videos and maps) that are embedded within our website. To accept all cookies, click 'I accept.'