Should reduce VAT across the board instead of supporting interest rates
January 11, 2022

Should reduce VAT across the board instead of supporting interest rates

January 11, 2022

Source: VnExpress.net

Considering that the most important support at this time is not the relief package but how to keep the economy open continuously and sustainably, Mr. Vu Thanh Tu Anh proposed spending more on healthcare and reducing VAT across the board.

It is expected that this afternoon (January 11), National Assembly deputies will vote to pass a Resolution on fiscal and monetary policy to have a support package for the socio-economic recovery and development program.

Sharing with VnExpress, Dr. Vu Thanh Tu Anh, Director of the Fulbright School of Public Policy and Management, said that this support package is necessary but should be prioritized for epidemic prevention and maintaining the continuous opening of the economy.

Dr. Vu Thanh Tu Anh, Director of Fulbright School of Public Policy and Management

What do you think about the proposed 340,000 billion VND fiscal and monetary policy support package?

- I think the support package is important but it is a bit unfortunate in terms of timing, when many countries - including the US and EU - have started to reduce the scale of their economic stimulus packages.

In terms of scale, the value is 340,000 billion but in reality, the amount of money pumped out will be much smaller. The reason is that on the one hand, we have to deduct the financial obligations that businesses will have to repay to the State after the period of deferment, extension, and maintaining the same debt group.

In addition, if the disbursement speed is slow, the low disbursement rate will reduce the effectiveness of the support package as has been the case with our packages in the past 2 years. The most difficult time for people and businesses when the whole country had to isolate for a long time and on a large scale has passed, so now I think we should not put all our hopes on this 340,000 billion VND package.

In short, in my opinion, the most important support solution at this time is the ability to open and maintain economic activities continuously and sustainably. Of course, I emphasize again, having a rescue package is still necessary instead of letting businesses and people swim on their own.

So what tasks should this 340,000 billion VND support package be "pumped" into to achieve the goal of maintaining the continuous opening of the economy as you said?

- The success of the support package depends on the priority, speed and effectiveness of implementation, so it is necessary to focus on some areas or subjects of higher importance. For example, investment in healthcare and epidemic prevention is expected to cost 60,000 billion. This task is very important, so depending on the epidemic situation, if necessary, this budget must even be increased. Because if the epidemic is controlled, the economy will open up in a stable and sustainable manner, which, as I said, is even more necessary than the support package.

The VND 113,800 billion for infrastructure investment is also necessary, helping to strengthen the competitive and efficient foundation for the economy. Infrastructure investment becomes more urgent in the context of FDI capital flows that may face many risks, private sector investment declines, and state sector investment last year was low. This is a measure to increase aggregate demand, while creating higher competitiveness in the medium and long term.

On the other hand, I think it is also necessary to prioritize education, especially for students in families with difficult or no access to high-quality equipment and Internet for online learning. This also aims to avoid creating serious inequalities in educational opportunities, affecting future career opportunities and human capital. Imagine the loss if a student does not receive quality education for two consecutive years, especially in the grades and levels that help shape thinking skills and knowledge base.

But if there is only 340,000 billion VND but we need to increase priority for healthcare and education, in your opinion, where can we cut to focus resources?

- I think the interest rate support package, currently about 40,000 billion VND, can be cut because it may still conflict with Vietnam's monetary policy, interest rate policy and inflation control target this year.

The biggest problem for businesses today is not a lack of credit. The banking system is not lacking in liquidity, the interest rate level is lower than the same period last year. Inflation in 2021 is also relatively low. When making a policy, we must see which problems of the economy it solves. Currently, I do not think that a lack of credit, or high-cost credit, is an important problem that needs to be solved through interest rate support.

What the economy lacks most at the moment is business opportunities, supply chains are broken, and production is stagnant. When injecting more liquidity and supporting 2 percentage points of interest rates, these urgent issues are not resolved. Not only that, this may give rise to some macro consequences, especially when the timing of the bailout package coincides with the cycle of price index increase. Currently, inflation in the world is increasing very quickly, and it will be imported into Vietnam in the form of raw material costs and energy prices. At that time, combined with the domestic economic recovery momentum, it will create demand-pull and cost-push, causing Vietnam's inflation to increase. This is also a risk when Vietnam's support package is out of sync with the world in terms of timing as I mentioned above.

Some National Assembly deputies believe that the bailout package is not to rescue weak businesses but to restore the whole economy, that is, to prioritize healthy businesses. What is your opinion?

- If the goal at this time is to restore the economy, recreate jobs, and support social security, it is impossible to target a few large enterprises. A few large enterprises will not be able to ensure jobs for millions of people who have lost their jobs or suffered from labor shortages in the recent past.

My point of view is that the State must create an environment in which there is equal access for businesses of different sizes in the same field to be supported. For example, in the tourism industry, not only saving the big guys but also ensuring the same access to policies for all tourism businesses. Of course, there are industries that need more support than others, such as trade and services, which have been most severely affected in recent times.

But prioritizing targeted businesses will create momentum for other businesses to recover?

- In theory, when the support budget is limited, the target must be as precise as possible. But the reality of many countries in recent times shows that targeting policies are correct in theory, but not easy to implement and therefore often do not achieve the expected results. The reason is that in order to implement a "target" policy, the implementing agencies must distinguish which businesses are eligible for support and which are not, while in reality, they can operate in many industries and fields.

Not to mention, to identify priority businesses, management agencies must classify and to avoid the risk of wrongly supporting and then being responsible later, they will focus on administrative procedures and processes. This significantly reduces the speed and accessibility of businesses. This is a trade-off between on one side, fast speed but possible mistakes, and on the other side, very detailed criteria, very good in theory, but slow implementation and low disbursement rates. But our policy is already slow, if we continue like this for another 6 months, a year, when we look back, we will see that the effectiveness of using and distributing the support package is very limited. I think in the case of "relief" requiring fast speed and wide reach, we have to accept a second best policy instead of a perfect policy (first best).

If we do not pour money into reducing interest rates, and do not prioritize a few "exact addresses", then in your opinion, which solution will be fast and have a wide impact?

- I think reducing value added tax (VAT) across the board is the fastest and most effective at this time. Currently, the draft has proposed reducing VAT from 10% to 8% for a group of goods and services, except for a number of groups in industries with development advantages such as telecommunications, finance, banking, insurance, real estate business... But I think doing it across the board would be better. This will simplify the process for both businesses and management agencies, because in reality, businesses can operate in multiple industries and fields. With VAT, there is no need to create new apparatus or new procedures. The enforcement agency only needs to base on the correct records as usual to reduce taxes for businesses.

Reducing corporate income tax is also often mentioned. But the disadvantage is that for businesses in difficulty, they do not incur tax obligations, so they will not benefit. This tax only supports businesses that are doing well. As for VAT, whether it is profitable or not, it is beneficial.

In addition, an important feature of VAT is that the tax burden is shared between businesses and consumers, so when VAT is reduced, both parties benefit.

In short, if possible, I think that interest rate support should be transferred to other targets such as health care, education, or VAT should be reduced across the board, which will create better economic efficiency.

In addition to supporting the economy, the VND340,000 billion package also brings some consequences in terms of inflation risks and bad debt. In your opinion, how can we reduce these risks?

- Vietnam will certainly face a higher inflation rate in 2022. This is inevitable. We cannot avoid rising inflation when we have to import inflation from outside while the domestic economy is on the path to recovery.

Last year, economic growth was weak, and inflationary pressure was low even though money was still pumped out. This year, when the economy is gradually recovering, consumer demand and public procurement investment will both increase, pushing up aggregate demand. Meanwhile, aggregate supply has not recovered correspondingly, which will push up prices.

Bad debt may increase dramatically this year. The reason is that we previously allowed the debt group to remain the same by technical measures, so when the debt returned to its true nature, many debts that were not bad on the books now became bad debt in reality.

Therefore, to reduce the risk of bad debt and not put too much pressure on inflation, the first thing is not to pump money through interest rate support. Next is to ensure control of bad debt in the banking system. After the 2013-2014 period, the State Bank has had a lot of experience in this issue. Finally, it is to reduce the burden on monetary policy and increase the weight of fiscal policy.

What we are doing in monetary policy is in the right direction. I believe that once the State Bank maintains low interest rates, maintains the safety of the financial and monetary systems, ensures liquidity, and controls bad debts to avoid a collapse like the past two years, it has completed its mission. Then we should let the market operate according to its inherent laws.

In fact, we cannot avoid an increase in inflation in 2022, so we need to find ways to reduce bad debts and not put more pressure on monetary policy. Because the burden of monetary policy this year is certainly much greater than last year.

  • Phuong Anh

Related Articles

This site uses cookies to provide a better user experience.

Essential cookies are active by default and are necessary for the proper functioning of the website. Analytics cookies gather anonymous information for us to enhance and monitor the site. Performance cookies are employed by third parties to optimize their applications (such as videos and maps) that are embedded within our website. To accept all cookies, click 'I accept.'