Source: VnExpress.net
Huỳnh Thế Du*
"Most households own private houses attached to land, while land for transportation and green space is too little" - I have heard many foreign colleagues comment like that when we looked deeply into the data on housing and urban areas in Vietnam.
The statistics and comparison with other countries, especially countries that are more developed than Vietnam, show very clearly.
According to the 2019 Population and Housing Census, the rate of apartment buildings in Vietnam is only 2.2% and individual houses 97.8%. The home ownership rate of Vietnamese households is 88.1%, among the highest in the world.
In 2021, in Korea, individual houses accounted for 20.6% and apartment houses accounted for 79.4%. Of which, high-rise apartments accounted for 63.5%. The home ownership rate in this country is 56.1%.
The United States is considered a country with a large land area and a typical example of wasteful land use for housing, but the rate of single-family homes is only 65.9%, and apartment-style housing is 26.3%. The home ownership rate is 65.3%.
China is an extreme. However, their housing structure also follows the general trend of the development process. 95% of newly built houses in recent years are high-rise apartments. The home ownership rate of this country of more than 1.4 billion people is nearly 90%.
"Housing prices are too high compared to income, so many people cannot afford to buy a house" is an argument that is mentioned a lot in Vietnam. However, there is another reality.
Regarding the ability to own a house, analysis of Hanoi's data shows paradoxes. According to official statistics, in Hanoi, the average income of a person in the lowest 20% in 2020 was 25 million VND/year and the average housing area was over 20 m2/person; the average area of households living in non-permanent houses was 15 m2/person.
In 2019, in Hanoi, 83.9% of households owned their own homes, while only 14.7% rented, the rest lived in other types of houses; and 87.1% of households lived in single-family homes. Since most households live and own single-family homes attached to land, the current market price is unlikely to be below VND50 million/m2. In other words, the average housing value of the 20% lowest-income group in Hanoi is unlikely to be below VND1 billion, or 40 years of their income. However, the actual amount that most households have to spend to own the house they live in, converted to current value, is generally below VND10 million/m2, which is within their ability to pay.
This seemingly impossible thing happened because of the very unique form of housing development in Vietnam. Because most households have been living in their multi-billion-dollar houses for a long time, especially low-income households. About two decades ago, the price of agricultural land (but with the possibility of building houses informally) on the outskirts of Hanoi (outside a 5km radius from the center) was within the affordability of many families. The total construction cost (including land purchased through informal transfers) was equivalent to 30% of 30 years' income (discounted to present value).
The low cost is because these families do not have to pay for the construction of shared infrastructure and the construction quality is only at a minimum level. Therefore, the actual construction cost of these types of houses, according to estimates, is only about ⅓ of the construction cost of official developers, and ¼ of the selling price of current affordable apartments. As a result, Vietnam has an urban structure with townhouses packed into small alleys with very little land for transportation and almost no land for greenery.
The above analysis shows that the secret for most Vietnamese households to own private houses attached to land, even in expensive urban areas, is to avoid the costs of building shared infrastructure (including allocating land for them). However, what is of concern is that the burden is pushed onto the whole society, making the quality of life of a very large part of the population in urban areas, especially the two central urban areas, very low. Urban areas cannot be civilized and modern with a high quality of life when the land for transportation is less than 10% and the green area is among the lowest in Asia.
In order for Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City to be able to allocate about 1/3 of their land area for transportation and green space, a feasible solution is to convert townhouses into high-rise apartments. Urban development from horizontal to vertical will be the future for Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City.
The future of Vietnam's urban areas depends on the choices and behaviors of the majority. If the mentality of having to have a piece of land to settle down is still dominant, Vietnam's urban areas, especially central urban areas, will remain cramped, dusty and congested as they are now. On the contrary, if the majority switch to high-rise living, there will be conditions to restructure the urban area to be more convenient with a better life.
To achieve this, a process with continuous solutions is needed. First is to change the majority's concept and perception of where to live. Next are the state's policies on planning, infrastructure development, and social amenities. When the above two things are achieved, the market, with its invisible hand, will function well to create spacious urban areas with high quality of life.
*Lecturer in Public Policy, Fulbright School of Public Policy and Management
Related Articles
