Source: VnExpress.net
For inter-regional projects, including Ho Chi Minh City, relevant localities should enjoy the city's special policies, according to experts' proposals.
The proposal was made by expert Nguyen Xuan Thanh, Fulbright School of Public Policy and Management, Fulbright University Vietnam, at the consultation session on the draft to replace Resolution 54 - piloting a number of special mechanisms and policies for the development of Ho Chi Minh City, on the morning of March 30.
This content has just been proposed by the Government to the National Assembly to add to the law and ordinance building program this year for approval at the May session under the shortened procedure. The new draft proposes 7 groups of special policies, with 40 articles, including investment management; finance, budget; urban and environmental resource management; attracting strategic investors; science and innovation management; organizational structure of Ho Chi Minh City and Thu Duc City.

Expert Nguyen Xuan Thanh, Fulbright School of Public Policy and Management, Fulbright University Vietnam, comments on the new draft replacing Resolution 54, on the morning of March 30. Photo: Thu Hang
According to Mr. Thanh, if we want to create a breakthrough, the new resolution should not be limited to Ho Chi Minh City. Instead, the city's projects that go through other localities, the People's Councils of the city and the provinces can decide on issues such as supplementing the budget, increasing investment costs... according to this superior mechanism.
"If so, the change in Ho Chi Minh City will have a widespread impact on the whole region, helping to solve many projects in the next three years," Mr. Thanh said, adding that one of the mechanisms that can be applied to inter-regional projects is to allow bidding and selecting investors to develop urban areas associated with public transport (TOD model).
Sharing the same view, Prof. Dr. Nguyen Trong Hoai, former Vice President of Ho Chi Minh City University of Economics, said that the breakthrough and outstanding mechanism must be more comprehensive to promote the city's regional spreading role. The overarching spirit of the resolution should be to delegate more power and control less, meaning that leaders must be more responsible and departments and branches must be more motivated to serve.
"However, the draft's delegation of power is not enough when many regulations still require the final steps to be approved by the National Assembly and the Prime Minister," he said, suggesting that the draft should approach from the perspective of expanding the scope of geographical space, because if approached from the city's limited resources, it will be very difficult to create a breakthrough.

Prof. Dr. Nguyen Trong Hoai, former Vice President of Ho Chi Minh City University of Economics, gave his opinion at the discussion on the morning of March 30. Photo: Thu Hang
In this draft, to attract investment for projects, Ho Chi Minh City proposed to re-apply the build-transfer method (BT contract) which had been "erased" since 2018. At the same time, the city requested an investment mechanism for projects in the fields of sports, cultural industry, museums, relics and cultural heritage under the public-private partnership (PPP) method; implementing BOT on existing roads.
Mr. Nguyen Xuan Thanh predicted that the proposal on BT contracts would encounter many controversies. Because this mechanism was previously criticized for being non-transparent and essentially avoiding public investment regulations. Therefore, to address this concern, the city needs to clarify that BT implementation will not exchange land for infrastructure, but will be paid from the budget with a transparent mechanism. The mechanism for reviewing total investment and selecting contractors still complies with public investment.
Meanwhile, Associate Professor Dr. Pham Duy Nghia, Fulbright University Vietnam, raised the issue of an imbalance in the capacity of the consulting team between the private sector and the government when implementing PPP projects. Accordingly, the contract is the law and anyone who violates it will be sued, including the government. While businesses have good lawyers and good advisors, the government "does not have the budget to pay lawyers to argue".
Based on that reality, this expert proposed that the city must have a PPP department with sufficient capacity in design, planning, project finance, and legal affairs to have a balanced position when negotiating with investors. "Negotiators must have enough capacity to jointly design, dialogue, and not let the private sector lead", he said and warned that PPP is a "double-edged sword", if not done properly, it will become an opportunity for the private sector and the government will have to take care of all the troubles later.
- Thu Hằng - Lê Tuyết
Related Articles
