Supervisors should be aware from the outset that Fulbright School MPP theses can take several forms. Some students will write a standard academic work normally associated with a master’s level thesis. In addition to standard theses, the MPP program also accepts work of a more practical nature, or “policy analysis exercises.” While policy analysis exercises must also have testable hypotheses, clearly stated research methods and results, their aim is to examine policy in a specific location or sector rather than address a theoretical question. Policy analysis exercises provide an opportunity for students to apply the skills that they have learned in their classes to policy issues of direct relevance to their professional interests.
Most Fulbright School theses fall into four broad categories:
- Quantitative analysis: This is a standard thesis in economics or a related field, consisting of a testable hypothesis based on sound theoretical principles, the use of secondary (or in some cases primary) data, a set of statistical methods to test the hypothesis, results and a conclusion. For example, a quantitative thesis may examine the relationship between tariff reductions in a specific industry and wage trends. Using an HOS model of international trade, the thesis would test the hypothesis that trade liberalization increases wages in labor intensive industries.
- Qualitative analysis: Some topics are best addressed using qualitative methods. Qualitative research still requires a theoretical basis, the formulation of an hypothesis, a method and results. However, qualitative analysis may use historical evidence, direct observation and interpretation in addition to quantitative evidence. For example, a quantitative thesis could examine the role of agricultural research on rice productivity growth in the 1990s. A quantitative analysis would include research spending or another instrument in a rice production function to capture the impact of technological change. By way of contrast, a qualitative thesis would interview people directly involved (leaders, researchers and farmers), cite historical and documentary evidence (for example, the origins and distribution of new seeds) and also refer to statistical information. Qualitative analysis is neither less rigorous nor easier than quantitative analysis. Indeed, it is actually more difficult to do good qualitative work, since it requires judgment and capacity for critical thinking. Thesis topics relating to law, governance and management are typically qualitative in nature.
- Project appraisal: Project appraisal is a specific kind of quantitative thesis that assesses an investment project on financial and/or economic grounds. Project appraisal is a popular type of thesis because of its direct relevance to the professional responsibilities of many FETP students. Moreover, the theoretical foundations are familiar to students and the hypothesis is not difficult to formulate (the project pays off or does not on an economic and/or financial basis). Students often have access to data from the departments in which they work. However, achieving high marks on a project appraisal thesis is generally quite difficult, because it requires an ability to go beyond the obvious costs and benefits and to think critically about the assumptions underlying the project.
- Policy case study: Policy cases are a specific form of qualitative analysis. Policy case studies are assessments of specific policies that explain why policies do or do not create public value. We can think of policy case studies as a qualitative version of cost-benefit analysis, although we should also note that case studies very frequently make use of statistical evidence (although perhaps not statistical modeling). For example, a student could conduct an assessment of government policies to stimulate international labor migration. The assessment could include a macroeconomic dimension that examines the impact on remittances, and also a microeconomic component that analyzes the impact on workers and their families. The thesis could compare Vietnam’s policy framework to that of other ASEAN countries and assess the extent to which workers are protected from abuse. Policy implications could include proposals to improve policies to enable the government to achieve its stated objectives, such as employment generation and poverty reduction.
Students may choose any topic that interests them as long as the thesis is relevant to public policy. We generally discourage purely theoretical theses. Among the most popular topics are project appraisal, local development initiatives (policy case studies) and topics relating to development finance and financial analysis.
